MORE DIALOGUE, PRACTICAL COOPERATION NEEDED

1403510719522 https://www.defencepioneer.sg/images/default-source/_migrated_english/1403510719522.jpg?sfvrsn=733066c4_2 https://www.defencepioneer.sg/pioneer-articles/MORE-DIALOGUE-PRACTICAL-COOPERATION-NEEDED
https://www.defencepioneer.sg/pioneer-articles/MORE-DIALOGUE-PRACTICAL-COOPERATION-NEEDED
MORE DIALOGUE, PRACTICAL COOPERATION NEEDED
16 Jul 2014 | Diplomacy

MORE DIALOGUE, PRACTICAL COOPERATION NEEDED

STORY // Koh Eng Beng
PHOTO // Chua Soon Lye & Chai Sian Liang

Defence leaders from Asia-Pacific, North America and Europe gather at the three-day Shangri-La Dialogue to find ways to mitigate and resolve key security challenges.

Rising tensions in the East and South China Seas, and the need for common principles to guide countries towards peaceful resolutions were top issues discussed at the 13th edition of the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) Asia Security Summit: The Shangri-La Dialogue, held this year from 30 May to 1 Jun.

The annual security forum was attended by 26 ministerial-level delegates as well as other senior defence officials, military top brass and academics from the Asia-Pacific region and beyond. This year's Shangri-la Dialogue was marked by frank and open discussions and the exchange of views on hot-button security issues.

Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe kicked off the Dialogue with a call for countries to observe international law to ensure peace in the region during his keynote address on 30 May: "It means making claims that are faithful in the light of international law, not resorting to force or coercion, and resolving all disputes through peaceful means."

Lack of strategic trust

Speaking at the final plenary session of the Dialogue, Minister for Defence Dr Ng Eng Hen said that regional countries must first overcome the lack of trust before there can be peaceful resolutions.

He noted that unlike in Europe, there was no binding aversion to war here. "Asia does not have the equivalent of the 'never again' resolve that bound all of Europe after two world wars, and that translated into political will to create formal structures and alliances to avoid war."

There are also fewer safeguards and structures to mitigate fallouts in Asia, where "unresolved historical baggage (and) animosities" exist among China, Japan and South Korea. Defence spending in Asia has also risen against world trends.

Dr Ng also warned that competition for resources, disputes over overeignty, and economic uncertainty could lead to instability. In addition, many countries' resolves are shaped by their individual histories. For example, China does not want a repeat of the "century of humiliation and unequal treaties" that occurred in the 19th century, and Japan wants to move on from the baggage of World War II, while ASEAN countries never again want to be colonised and exploited.

Thus the political challenge facing Asia, he said, is to ensure that these circles of aspirations and ambitions of individual countries intersect as much as possible.

"Asia must therefore build more resilient mechanisms to forge consensus and political will to prevent if not mitigate conflicts," he said.

Dialogue and cooperation

"Many have pointed out that strategic trust among Asian countries is lacking. We need to have open and frank dialogue on security challenges, like we are doing here, before they can be meaningfully addressed," said Dr Ng.

He urged countries to strengthen multilateral frameworks for dialogues, and to step up cooperation between militaries to forge trust among countries. He cited the ASEAN Defence Ministers' Meeting (ADMM) and ADMM-Plus as examples.

Formed only four years ago, the ADMM-Plus has moved from dialogue to practical outcome, paving the way for countries to work together. In June 2013, all 18 countries came together in Brunei to conduct a large-scale Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Relief (HADR) and Military Medicine exercise. Various countries also provided rapid HADR in the Typhoon Haiyan relief efforts and in the search for the missing Malaysia Airlines flight MH 370.

Dr Ng noted that concerted action to help one another in HADR is a key means of achieving trust. And he explained that this and the recent natural disasters that hit the region were the reasons Singapore offered to host a Regional HADR Coordination Centre.

This proposal was supported by the United States (US) Secretary of Defence Chuck Hagel in the opening plenary session of the Dialogue, who agreed that "ASEAN member states should consider Singapore s offer to use Changi Naval Base as another regional command and control hub".

US, China to up engagement

Mr Hagel also echoed Mr Abe's call for countries to observe international law, and pledged to ramp up the US' military presence in the region despite persistent budget woes. It planned to increase foreign military financing by 35 percent and military education and training by 40 percent by 2016.

"The rebalance is not a goal, not a promise, or a vision - it is a reality," he said.

Similarly, China pledged to advocate dialogues and cooperation, and will explore creating direct telephone links with ASEAN countries to manage differences and avoid miscalculations, said Lieutenant-General (LG) Wang Guanzhong, Deputy Chief of the General Staff of the People s Liberation Army, in his plenary speech.

"The security of China is closely linked to that of Asia... China is a constructive, proactive and positive force for Asia's peace and security," he said.

"Many have pointed out that strategic trust among Asian countries is lacking. We need to have open and frank dialogue on security challenges, like we are doing here (at the Dialogue), before they can be meaningfully addressed."
- Dr Ng


Suggested Reading
CREATING BONDS THROUGH MILITARY MEMORABILIA
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

Some collectors collect stamps, others, stickers. But ME2 (NS) Lim Geng Qi boasts a unique military memorabilia collection of over 1,200 items!

Lawyer by day, military artist by night
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

Photograph or painting? At this year’s Military Hobby Fest, we met 1SG (NS) Samuel Ling Ying Hong, a self-taught aviation oil painter who spends up to 50 hours on each realistic artwork.

Cover story
AIRBORNE!
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

Marking 10 years this December: The Singapore Armed Forces’ (SAF’s) one-of-a-kind training facility prepares trainees to become competent and confident airborne troopers.

IT RUNS IN THE FAMILY
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

The fourth child in Singapore’s first set of quintuplets, LTA Annabelle Chin Li En made a mid-career switch to follow in her parents’ footsteps and serve the country.

Flying High with Defence Innovation
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

A hybrid UAV with enhanced flight capabilities and software systems that analyse data from the Internet to detect online terrorism threats – these were some of the projects featured at this year’s Defence Technology Prize award ceremony. 

Cover story
NAVY RETIRES LAST OF ITS CHALLENGER-CLASS SUBMARINES
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

RSS Conqueror and RSS Chieftain were decommissioned today at Changi Naval Base, closing the chapter on more than two decades of service of Singapore’s first submarines.

OVERCOMING LOSS TO SERVE STRONG
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

The memory of her late mother became 3SG Reshma d/o Pulanthiradas’ greatest source of strength as she overcame challenges to graduate as a Logistics Specialist in the SAF.

SUITED UP FOR SUBMARINE ESCAPE TRAINING
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

Get an inside look at how the Navy drills its submariners on escape survival techniques, to prepare them for an emergency.

CYBER DEFENDERS TAKE ON NEW THREATS IN CLOUD AND AI IN NATIONAL EXERCISE
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

The third Critical Infrastructure Defence Exercise (CIDeX) brings together cyber defenders from across Singapore to face the ever-evolving challenges of digital threats. 

Cover story
WELCOME TO CAMP TILPAL
Diplomacy
16 Jul 2014

How do you house some 6,000 people and feed them for three months? You build a pop-up “city” – complete with accommodations and the basic comforts of home – for the thousands of SAF soldiers who train annually in Queensland, Australia.